War of Gujarati thalis – Thackers Vs Samrat

Sometime in August last year I visited a restaurant which is now my new favourite for vegetarian, especially Gujarati food. Thackers, at Girgaon Chowpatty a favourite among the Gujaratis living around that area. In a true foodie/Gujarati spirit, the locals queue up at Thackers for lunch/dinner every weekend. The restaurant serves an a la carte menu of Gujarati delicacies along with Continental and Indian dishes but is more famous for its Thali.

A short drive away from Thackers is Samrat restaurant located near Churchgate Station. This too, like Thackers is popular among those who love Gujarati food. Apart from traditional Gujarati thali restaurant also serves regular Indian and Continental food.

Last weekend, after a drive to Marine Drive with family we decided to go to Samrat for dinner. Since we’d picked it over Thackers I couldn’t stop myself from comparing the two. Here too, we ordered thalis and couple of dishes from the a la carte menu.

The thali at both the restaurants had traditional dishes including farsan (fried or steamed snack), subzis, dal, kadhi, rotis, puris, thepla, rice preparation, dessert and chaas (buttermilk). At Thackers we were served dhokla and bhajiya as farsan while Samrat served fried gawar ki fali (cluster beans), matar ki kachodi – deep fried Indian pastry stuffed with green peas and dhokla – steamed rice flour cakes. Farsan at both the places were good, we like the ones at Samrat a little more. I prefered the subzis served at Thackers; we were served aloo ki subzi, undhiyu and a palak subzi at Thackers. At Samrat we had chhole instead of the palak subzi. We also had Surti dal and kathol – a combination of pulses, at Thackers. The kadhi at Samrat was tad too sweet while the one at Thackers had a good balance of sweet, spicy and tangy flavours. Now coming to the most important part, rotis. Fresh, thin, hot and ghee laden rotis were served at Thackers but the ones at Samrat disappointed us. They were cold, uncooked and dry and even after repeated requests we weren’t served hot rotis, we had to switch to eating puris. The puran-poli and thepla was nice though.

From the a la carte menu at both the places we ordered panki – rice pancakes steamed in banana leaves. At Thackers (Rs 85) the panki was thin, hot and had a robust flavour of garlic. It came with a green chutney which complemented the dish perfectly. The panki at Samrat (Rs 140) was disappointing, it was thick, cold and had a stale taste. it was served with a green chilli pickle which couldn’t save the dish either.

Dessert was good if not great at Samrat, we had gulab jamuns and fruit custard. At Thackers we were served rasmalai which was a perfect end to the meal.

Apart from the quality of food there’s a vast difference in price too. While a thali at Thackers will cost you Rs 295 you’ll have to shell out Rs 355 at Samrat which is as much as the thali chains like Rajdhani, Maharaja Bhog and Panchvati Gaurav. However, these chains serve much better food with variety of dishes and quick service.

After trying out thalis at both Thackers and Samrat, my vote goes to the former for their authentic and fresh food, pleasant service and pocket friendly price.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s